LETTER TO EDITOR
Year : 2020 | Volume
: 36 | Issue : 4 | Page : 335--337
Author Reply Re: Elbaset MA, Ezzat O, Elgamal M, Sharaf MA, Elmeniar AM, Abdelhamid A et al. Supernormal differential renal function in adults with ureteropelvic junction obstruction: Does it really exist? Indian J Urol 2020;36:205-11
MA Elbaset, Yasser Osman
Urology Department, Urology and Nephrology Center, Mansoura University, Mansoura, Egypt
Dr. M A Elbaset
Urology Department, Urology and Nephrology Center, Mansoura University, Mansoura
|How to cite this article:|
Elbaset M A, Osman Y. Author Reply Re: Elbaset MA, Ezzat O, Elgamal M, Sharaf MA, Elmeniar AM, Abdelhamid A et al. Supernormal differential renal function in adults with ureteropelvic junction obstruction: Does it really exist? Indian J Urol 2020;36:205-11.Indian J Urol 2020;36:335-337
|How to cite this URL:|
Elbaset M A, Osman Y. Author Reply Re: Elbaset MA, Ezzat O, Elgamal M, Sharaf MA, Elmeniar AM, Abdelhamid A et al. Supernormal differential renal function in adults with ureteropelvic junction obstruction: Does it really exist? Indian J Urol 2020;36:205-11. Indian J Urol [serial online] 2020 [cited 2021 May 5 ];36:335-337
Available from: https://www.indianjurol.com/text.asp?2020/36/4/335/296771
We thank the readers for their queries about our work and believe that our reply will provide more details about this topic.
The old concept of Koffet al. mentioned in the author's comment is countered by new trends in managing patients with UPJO conservatively in case they are asymptomatic and the renal function is stable., In this report, not only did all patients have obstructed kidneys evident by renographic prolonged T½ (23 [16–34] min) but were also symptomatic (29 patients with recurrent flank pain and 2 patients presented with recurrent pyelonephritis). The decision of corrective surgery in this subset of patients could not depend only on T½ value but clinical symptoms as well.
We agree with the theory that renal hydronephrosis is not always a pathological sign but actually a compensating mechanism designed to protect the kidney from high pressures and renal damage. Loss of this adaptive mechanism initially leads to the appearance of patient's symptoms prior to renal function deterioration. Persistence of these symptoms with delayed intervention could initiate renal function deterioration.
We agree with the authors in the necessity of standardized methodology for renogram technique application; we described it thoroughly in the manuscript methodology. The amount of hydration, the fullness of the bladder, and the position of the patient are precautions that should be taken into consideration and are done routinely in our center to increase the accuracy of the renographic results. Evaluation of normalized residual activity, pelvic excretion efficiency, output efficiency, and cortical transit time are analogous to transit time, especially in the presence of standardized renogram protocol.,
Although computed tomography (CT) may be used to determine differential function, it cannot replace nuclear renal scan entirely to quantify obstruction. Authors in their comment mentioned a study done by Sarma et al. which was encountered by some limitations. If patients presented with acute on top of chronic pyelonephritis, renal tissue edema would hamper the accurate detection of renal volume. Second, most patients evaluated in chronic obstruction group had poorly functioning renal units. Accordingly, the use of CT-detected renal parenchymal volume as a predictor of differential renal function. (DRF) determination in the snDRF group is questionable. Finally, nephron damage may occur before measurable volume loss and the CT estimate may lag behind a renal scan to indicate decreasing function.
Which type of scintigraphy, 99 mTc-DMSA or 99 mTc-MAG3, should be used in the evaluation of DRF is still a matter of debate. Some authors considered that different isotopes could yield substantially different results in the same patient. On the other hand, it is proven that 99 mTc-DMSA and 99 mTc-MAG3 renograms in the evaluation of DRF are comparable. In a previous study, it was concluded that if a 99 mTc-MAG3 scan has been performed to assess drainage, a 99 mTc-DMSA scan specifically to estimate DRF is unnecessary, provided that the DRF is within normal limits on the 99 mTc-MAG3 scan and there is no proven scarring on previous imaging. Based on that, a 99 mTc-MAG3 renogram was done commonly at our center for adults in the evaluation of UPJO taking advantage of obstruction evaluation. Hence, we could not expose our patients to further radiation exposure by doing 99 mTc-DMSA. We could suppose that further prospective studies might open the horizons to fill those gaps in this topic of the literature.
|1||Malki M, Linton KD, Mackinnon R, Hall J. Conservative management of pelvi-ureteric junction obstruction (PUJO): Is it appropriate and if so what duration of follow-up is needed? BJU Int 2012;110:446-8.|
|2||Gulur DM, Young JG, Painter DJ, Keeley FX Jr., Timoney AG. How successful is the conservative management of pelvi-ureteric junction obstruction in adults? BJU Int 2009;103:1414-6.|
|3||Elbaset MA, Ezzat O, Elgamal M, Sharaf M, Elmeniar A, Abdelhamid A, et al. Supranormal differential renal function in adults with ureteropelvic junction obstruction: Does it really exist? Indian J Urol 2020;36:205-11.|
|4||Chandrasekharam V, Srinivas M, Bal C, Gupta A, Agarwala S, Mitra D, et al. Functional outcome after pyeloplasty for unilateral symptomatic hydronephrosis. Pedia Sur Int 2001;17:524-7.|
|5||Kuyvenhoven JD, Ham HR, Piepsz A. Optimal time window for measurement of renal output parameters. Nucl Med Rev Cent East Eur 2002;5:105-8.|
|6||Eskild-Jensen A, Gordon I, Piepsz A, Frøkiaer J. Interpretation of the renogram: Problems and pitfalls in hydronephrosis in children. BJU Int 2004;94:887-92.|
|7||Morrisroe SN, Su RR, Bae KT, Eisner BH, Hong C, Lahey S, et al. Differential renal function estimation using computerized tomography based renal parenchymal volume measurement. J Urol 2010;183:2289-93.|
|8||Ritchie G, Wilkinson AG, Prescott RJ. Comparison of differential renal function using technetium-99 m mercaptoacetyltriglycine (MAG3) and technetium-99 m dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA) renography in a pediatric population. Pediatric Radiology 2008;38:857-62.|